An experienced specialist adjusts a component on a test bench while the team leader discusses the measurement with him.

Overqualified or too expensive

How do I explain moving from leadership into a specialist role?

Two honest answers to explain the move

Moving from leadership into a specialist role often raises the same question in an interview: Why now, and don’t you miss being in a leadership role? Our practical view: an honest, concise answer is more convincing than a polished one.

Take Markus, 59, as an example. He managed the logistics team at a retail business for many years. During a reorganisation, his management position was removed. This was not the next step he had planned. While job hunting, he also looked at specialist roles and is now applying for a position in the scheduling department. There, he would once again plan routes and delivery dates himself.

His answer to the question about the move: «My management position was removed during a reorganisation. That wasn’t the next step I had planned. While looking for work, I also considered specialist roles. I’m interested in your scheduling department because I know route planning and coordinating with drivers well. I’d like to find out whether the role and the scope for making decisions are right for both sides.»

Markus doesn’t have to put a positive spin on losing his job or claim that he had always wanted to leave leadership. The circumstances explain why he is looking for work. The specific role explains why he is applying here.

If someone chose to make the move, their answer will sound different: «I managed a logistics team for a long time. Now I’d like to plan routes and delivery dates myself again. I know the scheduling work from our day-to-day operations and from covering during busy periods. That’s why I’m interested in your specialist role.» Only use experiences like these if they are true for you.

Both answers are honest, and both are valid. Even after losing your job involuntarily, you can seriously consider a specialist role without retrospectively claiming that the redundancy was what you wanted.

What will you decide yourself, and how will you work with management?

You can’t tell what the day-to-day work will be like from the job title alone. A specialist role may offer plenty of scope to make your own decisions, or it may involve tightly prescribed procedures. So Markus doesn’t promise without checking that he will set schedules and capacity on his own in future. He asks what a typical working day looks like.

His question about decision-making and working together: «Which decisions would I make myself in this specialist role? Which matters would you involve management in, and how would we coordinate day to day?» And, more specifically: «If two urgent orders come in at the same time, do I decide which comes first, or does management set the priority?»

He listens for whether responsibilities are clearly described. He also asks how suggestions on specialist matters are handled and who makes the decision if there is disagreement. He is not only checking whether he can fit in. He is also checking whether he can do good work in this role.

He describes his own approach like this: «I give my professional view and raise problems early. If management makes a decision after we’ve discussed it, I carry on on that basis. If I spot professional risks, I’ll raise them again.» Only use this if it reflects how you work. Leadership experience does not mean you have to take on team management on the side. Induction, acting as a deputy and personnel responsibility are different tasks. Make sure you clarify which of them are part of the role.

Your previous roles stay on your CV. A management position does not become an administrative role retrospectively. In his profile, Markus writes: «Logistics planner with leadership experience. I’m looking for a specialist role in scheduling, where I can plan routes and delivery dates myself again.» There’s no need to mention the job loss in the profile line. You can explain the circumstances factually in your cover letter or interview.

If asked whether he misses being in a leadership role, Markus replies: «What I valued about leadership was planning together. I’m interested in your role because I’d be working on the planning myself again. I’d like to understand more about how I’d work with your management team.» If you’re still unsure whether that would be enough for you, use the interview to find out. Don’t promise in advance that you’ll never miss being in a leadership role. Ask for an example of a task and who would be responsible for what.

For other objections, see the answers to «overqualified». If salary comes up, read what to say if someone thinks you’re too expensive. For the written part, you’ll find examples under why you want this job.

At CARERO by SeniorsAtWork, we think it helps to practise answers like these out loud in advance. In the Interview Coach, you can practise questions such as «Don’t you miss being in a leadership role?», tailored to the job.

Your task for today

Set aside 15 minutes. Write three sentences: What happened, or what did you decide to do deliberately? Which task interests you? What relevant experience do you bring? Add your question about decision-making. Read everything out loud and cross out any sentence that puts a positive spin on losing your job or promises responsibility that hasn’t been agreed.

Markus and the jobs in this article are fictional.

Frequently asked questions

How can I check for myself whether it’s a good fit?

Check your answer against three questions: Have I described the reason honestly? Can I name a specialist task and relevant experience of my own? Have I prepared a question about decision-making and working together?

Is moving into a specialist role a step backwards?

Not necessarily. What matters is whether the tasks, conditions and responsibilities suit you. Even after losing your job, you can consider a specialist role without having to put a positive spin on what happened.

How do I explain the move on my CV?

In one line in your profile: specialist role, task, responsibility. That’s all you need there.

What should I say if they ask whether I miss being in a leadership role?

Describe what you valued about leadership and what interests you about the new role. If you’re unsure, ask about the day-to-day work rather than promising that you’ll be satisfied in the long term.

What if the new job pays less?

Be open about choosing the role, and discuss the salary in the interview. For advice on how to talk about it matter-of-factly, see the article on what to say if someone thinks you’re too expensive.

What if my future manager is younger than me?

Then it’s the role that matters, not your age. For advice on how to raise this in the interview, see the article on what to do if you’re interviewed by someone much younger.

Was this article interesting?

Read more