
Job interview
Should I follow up after a rejection?
Turn feedback into your next answer
A rejection hurts, even when you were expecting it. Our view: it’s most useful when you take away one pointer that you can explain better next time. You don’t have to overhaul your entire application.
Let’s take Martina, 58, as an example. She works in administration and had a face-to-face interview. Afterwards, she receives this feedback: «We would have liked to hear more about your experience with system changes.» To begin with, this only means that her experience wasn’t clear enough to this interviewer. It doesn’t mean she lacks that experience.
In the interview, Martina had only said: «I’ve supported several transitions.» The feedback shows her what was missing: What was her own role? What problem did she tackle? Rather than listing more years of experience, she prepares one project: «When our new order-processing software was introduced, I coordinated the transition in the administration team. The data from the old system didn’t fit the new format. I worked with IT to create a transition list, checked the data transfer using test orders and showed my colleagues the new processes.»
This answer shows her own role, a problem and a specific action. Only include what you actually did. If you weren’t responsible for the introduction, you could say: «I entered the test orders and reported incorrect allocations to the project manager.» Clearly describing even a smaller part of the work helps make your experience visible.
When is it worth following up? After a standard rejection without an interview, you’re unlikely to get much specific feedback, and you don’t need to chase it. After a face-to-face interview, it’s worth sending a short message within a few days, while they still remember you. After the final round, following up is usually appropriate, and you can offer a brief phone call. This is our view, not a hard-and-fast rule.
Don’t ask: «Why wasn’t I chosen?» That kind of question can put the other person on the defensive. Ask for a pointer about how you came across. A specific question is often easier to answer.
Not every response gives you something useful to work on. One piece of feedback doesn’t explain the whole selection process, and you can’t infer that your age was the reason from a vague rejection. If your age is explicitly mentioned in a disparaging way, you don’t have to accept it as fair, objective criticism. Make a note of the exact wording for yourself, then decide once you’ve had some time to reflect whether you’d like to seek advice. Following up isn’t a request to reverse the decision, so don’t argue against it point by point.
Two messages you can adapt
Replace the name and day of the interview, and check that the suggested way of keeping in touch works for you.
«Dear [Name], Thank you again for meeting with me on Tuesday. If you’re able to give me a brief pointer, what could I have explained more clearly in the interview? It would help me with future applications. Kind regards, [your name]»
«Dear [Name], Thank you again for the open conversations over the past few weeks. If you’re able to give me a brief pointer, what could I have explained more clearly for this role? If a short phone call would be easier, please feel free to suggest a time. Kind regards, [your name]»
If you don’t get a reply, you won’t know the reason. Ask once, then move on to your next application. The article on introducing yourself in an interview explains how to present yourself clearly from the outset.
At CARERO by SeniorsAtWork, we believe it’s an advantage to follow up calmly and politely after an interview. It shows confidence and keeps the door open, including for future roles.
Your task for today
Set aside 15 minutes. If you’ve had an interview recently and haven’t yet received feedback on how you came across, adapt one of the messages. If you’ve already received a specific pointer, write three sentences: What was my role? What was the problem? How did I solve it? Read your answer aloud once and remove anything you can’t back up with your own experience. After a standard rejection without an interview, you don’t need to write anything today. Instead, find a specific example for your next application.
Martina and the situations in this article are fictional.
Frequently asked questions
How can I decide for myself whether it’s appropriate?
Check your follow-up against three questions: Did I have a face-to-face interview or reach the final round? Is it one short, friendly question? Can I carry on with my job search if I don’t get a reply?
What should I do if I don’t get a reply?
If you don’t get a reply, you won’t know the reason. Ask once, then move on to your next application.
How do I acknowledge specific feedback?
In one sentence: «Thank you for the feedback. I’ll prepare that example for my next interview.»
How soon should I write after a rejection?
Write within a few days if possible. But wait until you can phrase your message calmly and objectively.
What if the rejection seems unfair?
Give yourself a day before you write. A short, friendly question is to your advantage.
Can I stay in touch after a rejection?
Yes, if you’re still interested in the organisation. You could write: «I’d be pleased to stay in touch should a suitable role come up in future.» This doesn’t guarantee you’ll be invited to interview for a future vacancy.
Was this article interesting?
Read more

Job interview
How should I introduce myself in a job interview?



No interview invitations